The New York Steak and Ribeye can be confusing because they have similar appearance and size. While both are premium cuts of beef obtained from the rib section of the steer, you may need to choose one of them because they differ in several ways.
The Ribeye steak is better than the New York strip. This is because the main difference between the two cuts is based on marbling and fat distribution. Ribeye is characterized by plenty of marbling and fats, which adds incredible flavor and moisture to the steak. The New York steak is thin, with a tight meat grain and a strip of fat on one side.
Although Ribeye is packed with an incredible amount of marbling and fats, it does not mean that it is always the best option. For instance, someone looking for a healthy option will prefer the New York strip to the ribeye steak. Keep reading for more insights on choosing the best steak for your needs.
The New York Strip
The New York Strip is also known as Kansas City Steak, Top Loin, Strip Steak, Top Sirloin, Porterhouse, and Ambassador Steak. It is obtained from the short loin and has a lower fat content than the Ribeye. Often, the steak is sold boneless, but you can get bone-in if you request.
When comparing New York Strip and ribeye health-wise, the New York Strip wins because it has less fat distribution. However, the Ribeye features intensive marbling and fat distribution, making it tender and tastier.
The Best Cooking Method
Besides the differences between New York steak vs. Ribeye, you also need to know the best method to deploy for cooking each of the two steaks for the best results. If you choose the right cooking method for each steak, you will likely get the best results.
Since the New York Strip has little marbling, the best cooking technique is fast cooking to make the steak tender and delicious.
Heat your grill to 900 degrees F before placing your seasoned New York Strip on the grates, and keep flipping it every 30 seconds.
Besides grilling the New York Steak at a high temperature, you can also pan-fry until it is 5-10 degrees from the target doneness.
Additionally, when cooking the steak, always let it rest before slicing.
What Is Ribeye Steak?
The Ribeye steak is also known as beauty steak, Spencer, scotch filet, Delmonico, Entrecote, or Market steak. It is cut from the Longissimus Dorsi muscles. Since the muscles that run from the spine’s side from the neck to the hips are rarely used, the steak is tender and best cooked quickly.
The Ribeye steak is characterized by loose-grained marbling with high-fat content that makes the steak tender with an intensive buttery flavor. It is best to buy the steak with the bone to retain extra moisture for a juicy and delicious steak.
Best Cooking Methods
One of the common methods to cook ribeye steak is two-zone grilling which allows effective temperature control when cooking the steak to ensure that you do not overcook it.
The high fat in the Ribeye steak causes flare-ups; therefore, it is not a good idea to leave the steak unattended. Again, when searing the steak, use high heat to brown the exterior while checking the doneness of the meat using a digital meat thermometer.
The second cooking method is reverse searing. Reverse searing involves searing the meat at a lower temperature and then searing it at a high temperature. The process entails searing the meat on a skillet after cooking it in the oven. For the best results, preheat your oven to 275 degrees F and then cook the ribeye steak until it reaches an internal temperature of 95 degrees F. After that, sear each side on a pan or a grill until you get a crispy crust.
Which Is More Tender Ribeye Or New York Strip?
The Ribeye steak is more tender than the New York Strip. This is because the ribeye steak is cut from the Longissimus Dorsi muscle, which is rarely overworked. Also, the steak is well-marbled with plenty of fat, contributing to its general tenderness and intensive flavor.
If you are looking for a tender, delicious, and juicy steak between the New York Steak and Ribeye, the steak will serve you right.
Which Is Better: New York Strip Or Ribeye?
Both the New York Strip and the Ribeye steak are great cuts of meat. Therefore, the answer to this question depends on the individual. For instance, the New York Strip will be the best option if you are looking for a more healthy cut. This is because it does not have a lot of fat, but it is delicious if you cook it well.
On the other hand, the Ribeye steak will be an ideal option for tender, juicy and flavorful meat.
Whenever you have to compare New York Steak Vs. Ribeye and choose the best, you must consider several factors, including health, taste and preferences, and the cooking method, before making your final decision.
Which Is More Expensive, Ribeye Or New York Strip?
When comparing New York Steak Vs. Ribeye in terms of price, the Ribeye steak is more expensive than the New York strip. On average, the cost of Ribeye is $12-$16 per pound, while the cost of the New York strip is between $10 to $15 per pound.
New York Steak Vs. Ribeye: Main Differences
The New York Strip and Ribeye steak are premium cuts that any steak enthusiast may want to try out. However, they differ in flavor, price, texture, and use.
1. The Flavor Profile
One of the main differences between the two cuts is based on marbling and fat content. The ribeye steak is characterized by intensive marbling and more fats, which translate into an amazing flavor when the steak is perfectly cooked.
While the New York Strip has fats and marbling throughout the steak, it is less than what the Ribeye has.
Hence, a ribeye steak has a more pronounced and delicious flavor than the New York Strip.
2. The Texture
The fat concentration on the two premium cuts is also responsible for varying texture. The Ribeye and the New York Strip are more tender than most cuts from the muscled parts of an animal, such as the flank and the chuck steak.
However, it is important to note that the ribeye steak is more tender due to its intensive marbling and high-fat content. Still, the New York strip can serve you right.
Regarding nutritional value, there is not much difference between these two steaks because they are derived from the same animal. Like most beef steaks, the Ribeye and New York Strip are rich in proteins and other essential nutrients, including iron, zinc, and vitamin D.
Again, since Ribeye steak has more fat content, it has a higher percentage of calories. The New York Strip allows you to remove the surrounding fat content before eating if you like your steak more healthy.
4. Cooking Method
You can always embrace several cooking methods when cooking your steak, including pan searing, reverse searing, grilling, air frying, or even sous vide. The NY strip is better grilled or cooked in high temperatures since it has a low-fat content.
New York Steak Vs. Ribeye; Similarities
The New York Steak Vs. Ribeye are mostly compared because they have similarities and differences. After looking at their differences, you may want to understand the similarities between the two cuts.
- Both the Ribeye steak and New York strips are obtained from less-used muscles of the backbone of the animal.
- The cost of the two steaks differs slightly.
- When cooking either of the steaks, you can sear them to brown the exterior and create a crispy texture.
- They are both juicy and more flavorful than most beef cuts
After examining the differences between New York Steak Vs. Ribeye, you should easily decide which one to buy. Both steaks have their advantages and disadvantages. Therefore, you should examine your needs and preferences before making your choice. If you need a tender and flavorful steak, go for Ribeye. The New York Strip is ideal if you want a healthy steak.
Scot has loved smoking food in his free time for the last few years. Each major holiday or off-weekend, Scot spends days testing and prepping new recipes for perfection.