Skip to Content

What Are The Best Baked Potato Toppings [TOP 10 OPTIONS]

What Are The Best Baked Potato Toppings [TOP 10 OPTIONS]

With the right baked potato toppings, you can quickly turn your ordinary potatoes into an incredible meal for everyone. However, with the numerous potato toppings to choose from, deciding on the best-baked potato topping may not be easy.

Although there are numerous potato toppings for you to choose from, cheddar cheese, mushrooms, pepperoni, Greek Yogurt, chicken, and Tuna are some of the best potato toppings that can quickly transform your baked potatoes into a mouthwatering delicacy.

If you have difficulties deciding on the best potato toppings to use for your next potato meal, you should read on for genius ideas and the best toppings you can try.

big potato cheese

What To Put On Baked Potato

A well-baked potato is pillowy in the middle and crispy on the outside. Cracking it open will prompt you to add a topping of your liking ranging from cheese to Greek yogurt. If you do not have specific toppings in mind, you will likely find it hard to decide what to add to your baked potato. Here are some of the best options that you need to try out.


Any edible mushrooms prepared well can be a great addition to your baked potatoes. For many, baked potatoes topped with mushrooms and fresh herbs are elevated types of potatoes that anyone can find delicious. When cooking your mushrooms, you must ensure that you cook them in a skillet until they become juicy and soft.


You are probably trying to imagine how the pumpkin topping will taste. First, using a pumpkin as a baked potato topping is ideal for using pumpkin leftovers. Secondly, although it does not sound appetizing, this is one of the toppings that can impact the general taste of your baked potato.

Cheddar Cheese

Baked potatoes go perfectly well with cheddar cheese. Many food lovers consider cheddar cheese a classic recipe for baked potato toppings. To get the most out of the cheddar cheese topping, you need to settle for freshly grated cheese, sour cream, and thick-cut pepper bacon.


The pepperoni is another excellent topping you may want to try out for a twist on a pizza night. A mixture of mozzarella cheese, pizza sauce, pepperoni, and fresh basil will make your potato quite delicious.


Baked potatoes with egg toppings can be an excellent replacement for home fries. The addition of bacon will leave you craving for more.

Greek Yogurt

Some people have the impression that loaded potatoes need to be heavy. The truth is that they do not have to be because the light option is even sweeter. Using Greek yogurt as your baked potato adding will liven up your baked potatoes.


Ratatouille provides an incredible opportunity to eat different vegetables in one go. Considering the health benefits of vegetables, this is one of the best potato toppings you do not want to overlook.

Besides, it is easy to use since you only need to take a pot of wonder ratatouille and pile it on top of your baked potatoes. You will need to add herb goats, cheese, and garlic for extra creaminess.


The Tex-Mex may be one of the healthiest baked potato toppings that you have not probably tried. If you love Mexican delicacies, then the Tex-Mex is not likely to disappoint you as it has lots of spicy beans, avocado, salsa, and coriander.


You can do anything with hummus, and a baked potato is no different. The creaminess of hummus is a perfect pair of fluffy inside a potato. Chopped sun-dried tomatoes and four tablespoons of hummus will provide you with a satisfying potato meal.

Creamy Harissa Tuna

Creamy harissa and tuna together make a delicious meal. All you need is to mix a reasonable amount of Greek yogurt and harissa and combine to make a smooth mixture that you can load into your baked potato. It is all about getting creative, and you will have crazy and tasty ideas to try out.

Loaded Baked Potato

Loaded baked potato makes an impressive and comfortable meal to eat at home as long as you have the right topping. Without the right toppings and a flawless cooking procedure, you might not like them very much. This explains why you need an expert understanding of making loaded baked potatoes. Here is a step-by-step guide to preparing the best loaded baked potato.

Step 1: After washing your potatoes well, use a fork to prick them well before rubbing them with olive oil and salt. Set your oven to 400 degrees F and bake the potatoes for about an hour until they become tender.

Step 2: Bake sliced bacon until they turn golden brown and crispy before chopping them into pieces and setting them aside. This quick process should take about 20 minutes of your time.

Step 3: Use a grater to shred cheese and add sliced scallion whites, butter, and chopped chives to a bowl.

Step 4: Cut the potatoes, scoop out the flesh, and put it into a bowl of butter. Put the potato shells on a foil.

Step 5: Mash the butter and potato mixture until the butter melts away. Add cheese, bacon, garlic powder, sour cream, salt, milk, and pepper. Whisk to combine.

Step 6: Divide the mixture between the shells and sprinkle them with cheese. Bake for about 8 minutes until the cheese is melted. Sprinkle it with scallion greens, bacon, and sour cream. The baked potato meal is ready to serve.

What Toppings Do You Put On A Baked Sweet Potato?

Anyone with an insatiable appetite may have tried sweet potato without and with different toppings. There is no doubt that toppings make a huge difference when preparing a delicious sweet potato meal.

If you are trying to ponder the best toppings for your baked sweet potatoes, here is a list of some of the best toppings you need to try.

  • Hot sauce and cottage cheese
  • Honey and bacon
  • Chile crisp and cucumber
  • Parmesan and Bolognese sauce
  • Egg, bacon, and cheese
  • BBQ sauce and pulled meat combine
  • Pineapple and Hawaiian ham
  • Eggs, bacon, tomatoes, and avocado combined
  • Fish and yogurt combine
  • Pizza toppings
  • Hot sauce, chicken, and ranch
  • Pomegranate seeds and green sauce
  • Chili crisp and cucumber

Baked Potato Bar Ideas

A baked potato bar is a buffet of baked potatoes and different toppings. It is a type of creative cooking that gives you a rare opportunity to impress your guests without necessarily spending a lot of money.

Like it is in any meal, you need to be a bit creative to prepare a delicious baked potato bar. One of the steps to cooking the best-baked potato bar is to understand some of the best-baked potato bar toppings clearly. They include;

  • Chives
  • Broccoli
  • Diced onions
  • Salsa
  • Butter
  • Chili
  • Butter
  • Sour cream
  • Crumbled bacon

The Kind Of Potato To Use

While any potato can give you a potato bar, it is good to understand that for best results, you need to go for sweet potatoes and russet. These two are best for baked potato bars because they are starchy and can easily make the fluffiest potato. Further, they come in a much larger size, implying that you will have sizable bars.

little potatoes baked

How To Make Baked Potatoes On A Grill

Baking your favorite potatoes on a grill is straightforward, depending on the quantity you are preparing. All you need to do is scrub them well and sprinkle them with salt before wrapping them tightly in foil and placing them on the hottest part of the grill. It will take about 45-60 minutes before they are ready.


Baked potatoes make a delicious meal if you are willing to prepare them with the right expertise. The toppings liven your baked potatoes and make them even more delicious. You are guaranteed a great meal with cheddar cheese, mushrooms, pepperoni, Greek Yogurt, and even chicken toppings.